Pins & Needles Comedy Holiday Show NYC: Stand-Up, Live Tattooing, and a Packed Night at Secret Pour
The Pins & Needles Comedy Holiday Show lit up New York City on December 17, 2025, delivering a sold-out-style night of stand-up comedy and tattoo-inspired performance at Secret Pour (1114 DeKalb Ave). Hosted, as always, by Taylor Drew and Justin Hartmann, the holiday edition of Pins & Needles Comedy leaned fully into its identity as one of the most distinctive live comedy shows in NYC.
This special holiday show combined sharp stand-up, a festive atmosphere, and the visual language that has made Pins & Needles Comedy instantly recognizable in the New York City comedy scene.
A Holiday Comedy Show Built for NYC
The December 17th Pins & Needles Comedy Holiday Show kept the format tight and intentional while adding seasonal elements that matched the venue and crowd. Holiday-themed visuals, live tattooing, and prize giveaways ran alongside full stand-up sets, creating an experience that felt curated rather than chaotic.
Taylor Drew and Justin Hartmann anchored the night as hosts, guiding the audience through the lineup with clean transitions and consistent pacing. Their ongoing role as hosts gives Pins & Needles Comedy its structure and has become a key reason the show stands out among NYC comedy events.
The Lineup: December 17, 2025 at Secret Pour
The holiday lineup reflected the show’s commitment to strong, distinct comedic voices.
Laramie Flick opened the show, setting the tone early with a focused opening set that warmed up the room and established momentum from the start.
Crenshaw and Thalia Herrera were featured performers, each delivering confident sets that balanced energy, timing, and crowd awareness. Their performances fit seamlessly into the Pins & Needles Comedy format, reinforcing the show’s reputation for thoughtful curation.
Headlining the holiday show was Marty Cunnie, who closed the night with a commanding set that brought the room together. His performance capped off the evening with clarity and confidence, making him a natural choice to headline the Pins & Needles Comedy Holiday Show.
Why the Pins & Needles Comedy Holiday Show Worked
The December 17th holiday edition highlighted exactly why Pins & Needles Comedy has become a recognizable name in New York City stand-up comedy. The show prioritizes:
-
Consistent hosting by Taylor Drew and Justin Hartmann
-
Carefully curated comedy lineups
-
Integration of tattoo culture without overshadowing stand-up
-
NYC venues like Secret Pour that support intimate, high-energy shows
Rather than relying on holiday gimmicks, the show used the seasonal theme to enhance what already works: strong comedy, clear identity, and a crowd that knows why they’re there.
Event Details
Pins & Needles Comedy – Holiday Show
Date: December 17, 2025
Venue: Secret Pour, 1114 DeKalb Ave, New York City
Hosts: Taylor Drew & Justin Hartmann
Opener: Laramie Flick
Featuring: Crenshaw, Thalia Herrera
Headliner: Marty Cunnie
Final Take
The Pins & Needles Comedy Holiday Show on December 17, 2025 at Secret Pour was a standout NYC comedy event that blended seasonal energy with high-quality stand-up. With a strong opener in Laramie Flick, memorable sets from Crenshaw and Thalia Herrera, and a confident headlining performance by Marty Cunnie, the night delivered a complete New York City comedy experience—anchored, as always, by hosts Taylor Drew and Justin Hartmann.
